Catalans Dragons v Saints - Preview

Table toppers going into the weekend of Round 7, Saints face a tough assignment to guarantee ending the weekend top of the pile when they visit Catalans Dragons on Saturday night (April 6, kick-off 8.05pm).

Paul Wellens’ side climbed to the Super League summit with a 12-4 win over Wigan on Good Friday. That ended the Warriors 15-match unbeaten run in the league and showed that actually - despite their hubristic and incessant barfing on about their recruitment - they haven’t pulled away from the most successful side in the Super League era. Both sides now have one league defeat on their record in 2024, with Saints having gone down to Salford following Mark Percival’s red card a month ago,


The centre served a two-match suspension for that and is out again for the trip to France. This time his absence is due to concussion protocols. Percival failed a head injury assessment (HIA) after being clobbered high by the shoulder of Liam Byrne. The Wigan man was handed a four-game ban at a tribunal hearing this week.


He’s not the only one involved in the Good Friday Disagreement who faces a suspension as a result. Saints will be without Matty Lees for two matches - this one against the other 2023 Grand Finalists and next week’s Challenge Cup quarter-final visit by Warrington - after the Match Review Panel (MRP) took a dim view of a shot on duplicitous, traitorous two-time Grand Final winner with Saints Luke Thompson. 


Lees clearly wanted to make an impression on his former colleague but in doing so could not avoid the kind of head contact that gets you sat down these days. There’s maybe an argument that a one-match ban would have sufficed but this is far from Lees’ first citing by the MRP, a fact which tends to go against him.


Lees is one of three from last week’s 21-man selection who is not involved this week. The most intriguing of these is probably Waqa Blake. There are some fairly unsavoury rumours circulating on the usual platforms about alleged breaches of discipline from Blake last weekend. These may or may not involve some rather low brow local watering holes and/or individuals among the female population of St Helens. We can’t really speculate too much but what we do know is that he is not playing in France. 


It was some surprise and frankly a disappointment that he didn’t play against Wigan either, but it means that only Percival will need to be replaced from the Good Friday three-quarter line. Ahead of fullback Jack Welsby Tommy Makinson made a glorious return from missing the double header with Leeds while Konrad Hurrell’s try put the seal on the win over Matty Peet’s ‘Invincibles’ at the end. Jon Bennison was the man preferred to Blake on the left wing and looks in line to make his 46th appearance for the club this week. 


Which just leaves Percival’s centre spot to fill. Wellens has talked this week about how keen Ben Davies is to be the man for the job but that enthusiasm won’t necessarily get him into the side. If he wasn’t the man when Percival was suspended and he wasn’t the man to come in even when he was named as 18th man specifically to cover for players lost to head injuries then he is unlikely to be the man this week. 


Which means that Wellens - a man who scored almost 200 tries in Super League and made almost 500 appearances for Saints in some of the most flamboyant sides in history will be taking the conservative option of relying on a back rower to fill the void. Don’t expect either Matt Whitley or Sione Mata’utia to go the length of the field to score but what you can expect as ever is for the Saints defence to be formidable.


Another question Wellens has been forced to contemplate this week is the one about Lewis Dodd’s future. There was some talk last year about the halfback trying his luck in the NRL when his Saints contract runs out at the end of this season. That idea seems to be back on the agenda but Wellens has declared himself relaxed about the situation. That’s either because he knows Dodd wants to stay, because he has a brilliant replacement in mind or…because like me he’s not really convinced that Dodd will get a halfback gig in the NRL. His kicking game still lacks variety while his decision to take on Jai Field following an early break in the derby was a mind-blowingly naive one. If Dodd is NRL material I’d still venture the opinion that he isn’t ready yet. For now he continues to learn and improve alongside the captain and quite often the dominant half Jonny Lomax. 


The hole left by Lees has a couple of obvious candidates competing to fill it. George Delaney should be delirious with hunger to play after being left out of the 17 on derby day. Prior to that he had featured in the last seven matches dating back to the home playoff win over Warrington in September. He may get the nod to start in a front row also boasting Alex Walmsley and ex-Wolf Daryl Clark. 


The alternative could be Morgan Knowles whose switches between prop and loose forward vary so little in style that they are barely visible. James Bell is back from a one-game ban picked up for an alleged hip drop in the cup win at Leeds so Wellens has the option to switch Knowles without losing anything at loose forward. Based on what Wellens has opted for so far this term expect Knowles to start at 13 and Delaney at prop with alterations on hold until the introduction of Bell from the bench. The rest of the back row should feature Curtis Sironen alongside whichever of Mata’utia and Whitley is not pressed into the centre role. 


That bench will probably feature Joe Batchelor after he passed an HIA despite not returning to the fray on Good Friday. Jake Wingfield is another fixture there since his return after missing the final four months of the 2023 campaign. Add Bell and that leaves one more spot, likely to be filled by the versatile Moses Mbye. 


The Dragons are another team with only one league loss on the slate in 2024. That came at Headingley in Round Three as the ropey Rhinos found one of their better performances of the season so far. They are also the team who ended Saints’ quest for five Grand Final wins in a row when THAT late Sam Tomkins try took the French side past Saints and into their second Grand Final in three seasons. They lost both, but remain a serious contender to reach Old Trafford again come October 12. 


Sironen will be disappointed to note that one of the three Dragons to miss out from the 21 on duty from their last fixture - a 32-24 win at Warrington - will be his brother Bayley. The others are impactful forward Jordan Dezaria and prolific tank on the flank Fouad Yaha. He has scored 67 tries in 110 Dragons appearances but is now finding appearances harder to come by with Toms Davies and Johnstone also at the club. Rumours that our own Tommy on the wing will be joining them for 2025 and a little beyond don’t seem to be going away. 


Fullback Arthur Mourge is one of the returning trio which should give McNamara’s side a running threat from kick returns. In the centres Adam Keighran has moved on to Wigan so perhaps Arthur Romano and Mathieu Laguerre will battle it out to partner former Sydney Rooster Matt Ikuvalu.


The French side made an eye-catching loan move for Hull KR halfback Jordan Abdull in the off season, and also took former Saint Theo Fages from Huddersfield Giants. In the absence of explosive stand-off and former Roosters and Melbourne Storm man Jayden Nikorima we may see Abdull and Fages link up in the halves. 


The Dragons may be the league’s French representatives but they still rely on a couple of gnarled English forwards. Mike McMeeken is a highly consistent performer who has managed England honours even among a generation of NRL-based alternatives, while Michael McIlorum is - as you might expect from a product of Shaun Wane era Wigan - euphemistically a highly physical player who is no stranger to a brightly coloured card. Yet he also gives McNamara’s side work rate and nous. His battle with Clark will be one to watch.  Either side of him at prop will be Julian Bousquet and another ex-Wigan man in Romain Navarette.  They also have that rarest of animals - a decent player who has played for Hull in the last five years - waiting on the bench in impact prop Chris Satae..   


With no Sironen and with last year’s pair Whitley and Mikael Goudemand now elsewhere, McNamara needs to find solutions in the back row. Though he has spent much of his time of late at prop McMeeken could slot in there and there is also Tariq Sims, veteran of over 230 NRL games most notably for the other Dragons of St George-Illawarra.  Benjamin Garcia celebrates his 31st birthday a day before this one kicks off and will no doubt add to his 219 appearances for Catalans over two spells, interrupted only by a season of inactivity with Penrith Panthers in 2016.  He may not have been a big hit on the other side of the world but Garcia remains among the top loose forwards in Super League.  Aside from Mourge the other returning pair for McNamara are also loose forwards in Frank Maria and Loan Castano.  

These teams met three times in 2023 including that playoff semi-final which finally ended Saints' four-year reign as champions.  Saints failed to win any of the three, going down 24-12 in Perpignan in May before being edged out 14-12 at home in July.  Yet you don't have to go back too far to find the last time Saints emerged from Peripignan victorious.  Kristian Woolf's side of 2022 went there and won 36-20 in April of that year with Welsby, Percival, Dodd, Batchelor, Knowles and Dan Norman all crossing for tries.  Makinson kicked six goals that night too, though given some of his feats from difficult positions over the last couple of weeks Lomax should be the one to whom the responsibility falls this week with Percival out of the reckoning.  

Last year's semi-final was a classic affair if you like your rugby league low scoring but physical but there have been others that stand out.  Saints got the better of the Dragons in the 2007 Challenge Cup final when Wellens crossed for a try to add to Ade Gardner's brace and further scores from James Roby and Paul Clough in a 30-8 success, the second of three cup final wins in succession under Daniel Anderson.  Fourteen years after that one the teams clashed again in the Super League Grand Final at Old Trafford. On that occasion it was a tight, low scoring affair as two Kevin Naiqama tries sealed a 12-10 win for the third of Saints' four in a row.  

A more unpleaseant memory from that year was the Magic Weekend meeting with McNamara's men at St James' Park in Newcastle when Saints led by 18 points with five minutes remaining but contrived to lose 31-30 in the kind of ludicrous comeback normally inflicted by Saints on to others.   

Past visits to the south of France have prompted much discussion regarding the club's travel plans, with many a defeat blamed on travelling too late or too early.  Wellens has already spoken of how keen he is to get the preparation right and revealed that the team will take a flight on Friday afternoon.  Which seems reasonable enough so that any shortcomings in the performance or a bad result should probably not be blamed on logistics.  

Like last week and the home games against Leigh and Salford earlier in the season this looks like being another close encounter.  In some ways it might be regarded as a must win if the gloss from the Easter triumph is not to be fully removed.  Yet in the grand scheme of things - and even after Wigan returned to the top of Super League following their win at Leigh on Thursday night - the reality is that there will still be much to play for in the 20 rounds that will remain when the hooter goes on this one.  

Squads;

Catalans Dragons;

1. Arthur 2. Tom Davies 3. Arthur Romano 4. Matthieu Laguerre 7. Théo Fages 8. Mike McMeeken 9. Micky McIlorum 10. Julian Bousquet 11. Tariq Sims 12. Paul Seguier 13. Benjamin Garcia 14. Alrix Da Costa 16. Romain Navarrete 17.César Rouge 18. Ugo Tison 20. Chris Satae 21. Matt Ikuvalu 24. Tom Johnstone 25. Loan Castano 27. Jordan Abdull 28. Franck Maria

Saints;

1. Jack Welsby, 2. Tommy Makinson, 5. Jon Bennsion, 6. Jonny Lomax, 7. Lewis Dodd, 8. Alex Walmsley, 9. Daryl Clark, 11. Sione Mata’utia, 12. Joe Batchelor, 13. Morgan Knowles, 14. Moses Mbye, 15. James Bell, 16. Curtis Sironen, 18. Jake Wingfield, 19. Matt Whitley, 20. George Delaney, 21. Ben Davies, 23. Konrad Hurrell,  24. Jake Burns, 25. Tee Ritson, 31. Noah Stephens.

Referee:  Liam Moore

Video Referee:  James Vella

No comments:

Post a Comment

Up The Jumper - Are modern tactics killing our game?

I should have written this sooner. In the midst of Saints’ four Grand Final wins in a row between 2019-2022 I was one of the few dissenting,...