There's no dressing this one up. It's one thing to lose a Challenge Cup semi-final. Another to lose it to your biggest rivals. Being held scoreless while conceding 32 points is a new realm of humiliation.
Nobody is pretending that this is the greatest ever Saints team. The 1996 vintage that their shirts pay homage to would make short work of them. But there are still standards which need to be met. This performance fell way short of the level deemed acceptable.
But let me clarify. I don't really think that this catastrophic shit show had anything to do with a lack of effort. I find it wearying when fans claim that they don't mind losing as long as the effort is there. They very much do. This 80-minute showing proved to me that you can put a shift in and still produce something of anger inducing atrocity.
Saints haven't been held scoreless since August 2024. That was also against Wigan. Paul Wellens' side went down 20-0 at the Magic Weekend at Elland Road, Leeds. They have not suffered this indignity in a Challenge Cup semi final.
The identity of the opponent and the added spotlight of free to a air television coverage add to the trauma of the experience. It scarcely gets any worse than this. Perhaps the 1989 Wembley final when Wigan - again - handed down a 27-0 flogging. But at least we could rationalise it with knowledge that Wigan were the only full time professional club in the UK at that time. There is nowhere to hide now.
There was a sign on the opening play that this might be the sort of day endured by Michael Douglas' D-Fens in Falling Down. Only his day wasn't really his fault. But nor was it Matty Lees' fault that he came out of the opening tackle of the game awkwardly and remained on the ground. After a long examination from the medical staff the skipper was helped from the field and didn't return. It didn't look great. He was making only his fifth appearance of the season after picking up an injury in the cup opener at Workington. He will be fortunate if he makes any more in 2026.
This left Saints boss Paul Rowley with a headache. He was forced to inject 36 year-old Alex Walmsley into the action only one minute in. Having selected Jonny Lomax on his bench Rowley only had George Delaney and Noah Stephens left to rotate into the pack once Walmsley had entered proceedings. Injuries to Curtis Sironen, Agnatius Paasi and Jake Wingfield would now bite that little bit harder. It all made the decision to leave in form back rower Jake Davies out of the 17 that bit more perplexing. But perhaps that's hindsight genius.
The performance and result was certainly something I didn't see coming. League form had been good coming in. Saints haven't lost in the league since the end of March. That run of four consecutive wins has elevated Saints to second in the table. By contrast Wigan's win over Bradford Bulls before this one ended a run of four straight league defeats. They sit fifth in the standings, four points adrift of Saints. None of which mattered here.
The awful truth is that you can win all the regular season games that come your way and it won't earn you the prestige and respect that comes with winning a Challenge Cup. The Super League weekly rounds are largely just manoeuvring yourself into a position from where you can make a charge for the Grand Final. They lack consequence. This was the biggest game of the season so far and Saints failed the test spectacularly.
It had looked reasonably promising early. Saints had the better of the possession and territory but the alarm bell sounded with how little they did with it. The Jack Welsby and Jackson Hastings halfback partnership was far less than the sum of its parts as Saints repeatedly looked lost when in striking distance of the Wigan line. Their defence was excellent but what was thrown at them often seemed directionless and uninspired.
By contrast Wigan were clinical. It seemed like they took every opportunity which came their way before half-time. That started with Jack Farrimond's opening try, the product of a wildly uncharacteristic mazy run from Warriors hooker Brad O'Neill. Four Saints defenders missed him as he almost went all the way himself before finding Farrimond on his inside. Adam Keighran's conversion and his penalty soon after gave Wigan an 8-0 lead.
Two more first half scores followed - both from winger Zach Eckersley - but it was Joe Wardle's opportunist effort just on half-time that erased what remained of our belief. Understandably trying to make something happen Joe Shorrocks tried to find Wright on half way. He could only find Wardle who tore unopposed under the Saints sticks. Saints had come out of a 14-point hole in eight minutes when the teams met a month ago. That made a 16-0 deficit feel within the realms, especially with the entire second half to play. But when Wardle's converted score pushed it out to 22-0 the cup dream felt over.
Which it was. The second half felt redundant. Wigan were comfortable. Even more so when Keighran and Farrimond added late scores. Their decision not to even take the conversion of the latter as time expired was a further blow to the collective ego of Rowley's side. For their part, the attack continued down the same blind alleys and never really threatened to alter the big duck egg on the scoreboard.
It's only one game but the magnitude of it should lead us toward some introspection. Which is a fancy way of asking where this leaves us. We have already taken a 52-10 hammering by Hull KR in the league and now we've been nilled by the neighbours we can't seem to get along with. One Easter miracle is all that separates us from the same problems we had against title rivals in the Paul Wellens era.
The buildup to this one saw new contracts or extension handed out, perhaps signalling the future direction of recruitment under new CEO Abi Ekoku. Shorrocks has had good games and not so good games. He's been better than I expected. But was he really worthy of a new three-year deal 10 games into his existing agreement? Does the erratic Lewis Murphy, who produced only rocks and forgot about the diamonds in the semi final, really justify another three years?
Then there's Alex Walmsley. One of the finest props in Super League and a big reason for Saints' success over the last decade. He has been given a more sensible one year deal but it should be remembered that he will be 37 shortly after the start of next season. He's already playing greatly reduced minutes and, while he has been effective, you worry about a sudden dip in his form as the body starts to wear. You get the sense Noah Stephens is going to become crucial over the next year or two.
But that's all for the future. Right now most of us will just be feeling a little hollowed out. A bit like I felt this week when I realised that it was possible for Reform and the Faragistas to take control of the town's council. It stings, as it should. But it is not the end of the fight. Feeling sorry for ourselves for too long is not a good option.
There's a Grand Final to play for.
No comments:
Post a Comment