Ray, The 14, Iggy And Another Defensive Shutout

It’s been an emotional, sometimes head scratching period for those of us in ‘that number’ and for the wider rugby league community.

First of all we lost a legendary figure in the game in Ray French. He passed away on July 26 at the age of 85. Given how he became synonymous with rugby league for his later work with the BBC it’s odd to think that he started out in rugby union. 


He played four times for England in 1961 before making the switch to league and to Saints from St Helens RUFC. Ray spent six years as a player with Saints and made over 200 appearances. They included the 1966 Challenge Cup final victory over Wigan where he featured at second row in a 21-2 win. 


But it was his work as a broadcaster and commentator for which he is known throughout rugby league circles and beyond. In 1981 he replaced Eddie Waring as the BBC’s main rugby league commentator. In doing so he became the voice of the sport for many in an era before live coverage of every match. 


I can still remember the Challenge Cup games and Great Britain internationals he called. His style was simple and enthusiastic, often excitable but never over the top. And though I’m sure he did his homework on all of the players he commentated on his responses to events on the field were natural. You didn’t get the sense that he had spent the previous week trying to come up with some Churchillian line to describe a try or a result like other sports commentators we could mention. Besides, whenever anyone got near to scoring a try he usually said ‘oh…he’s going for the line’ in his broad St Helens accent. Which did the job.


Ray was with the BBC until 2019 but his final TV commentary came six years earlier as Wales took on Italy in the 2013 World Cup. His Challenge Cup final highlights included the 1985 classic between Wigan and Hull and the 1996 epic in which his hometown Saints crawled out of a 14-point hole to beat Bradford Bulls 40-32 and so usher in a new era of success for the club.


By comparison the furore over the decision to extend Super League to 14 teams for 2026 seems trivial. But the direction of travel for our game is something that I am sure Ray cared deeply about. At a meeting of the clubs on July 28 the slightly barmy decision was taken to expand the top flight from the current 12 clubs to 14. This, they said in a statement, would be done by a combination of the IMG gradings and an ‘independent panel’.


The phrase ‘independent panel’ leaps out at you here. If the way that the return of previous failure Nigel Wood is anything to go by it will be anything but independent. It will consist - if not of Wood and the club owners themselves - then their stooges who will arrive with strict orders to come up with the ‘right’ 14 names. There have already been dark mutterings about whether or not to include Catalans Dragons in the new plans. 


To cast them aside now after 19 years would constitute an act of self harm. Ok, so they are terrible in 2025 but they have had success. They won the Challenge Cup in 2018, the League Leaders Shield in 2021 when they went on to reach the Grand Final and they also reached Old Trafford in 2023. They give the sport a presence in Europe which is important for the game’s profile and marketability, even if they do bring all of their away fans in the same taxi. 


They’re not perfect but they’re far from the only Super League club you can say that about. If there is a drive among club owners to get rid of French sides from Super League it comes from a place of xenophobia and of being too tight to pay for the travel and accommodation involved. Which couldn’t be any more small time as a philosophy. If it were up to club owners we would be subjected to derbies every other week and TV interest would likely shrink so that it consisted of a few clips on sports news bulletins in northern regions and a highlight programme buried where The Hit Man And Her used to be.


Even if the owners see that and keep the competition European it’s a mistake to go to 14 teams at the moment regardless of the make up of the league. Their just isn’t the depth in the playing pool. You only need look at the absolute state of Huddersfield Giants and Salford Red Devils in 2025 to see that. Salford have been beset with financial problems to the point where their presence in the league has meant at least one game in every Super League round has been non-competitive. Meanwhile Huddersfield have a less compelling excuse for being so awful. You may accuse me of wild speculation but I’m guessing the decision to abolish relegation based on wins and losses on the field has something to do with their level of motivation.


And it’s not the first time. Last year we had the farcical situation of London Broncos knowing they were going down to the Championship before a ball was kicked due to their lowly IMG grading. Before that we had Toronto withdrawing mid season as everyone struggled to deal with the pandemic. There’s always something. You can’t just stick Paul Vaughan in a Championship side and expect them to compete. That appears to be the only moved made as yet to try and bridge the gap. 


And where are IMG in all of this? Apparently their role is only to advise but what’s the point of introducing a grading system or making any other recommendations if you’re just going to go back to what you’ve always done? Are they just not being listened to and don’t care enough to make a scene publicly? After all they have a 12-year deal and will still get paid if my dystopian vision of the game’s future comes to pass. They have been nodded to in the statement with the claim that gradings will be considered but will they? Really?


Closer to home there has been retention rather than recruitment news at Saints. Agnatius Paasi has been among the most heavily criticised of the Saints forwards this year by fans, especially during some of the team’s more anaemic performances. Yet that hasn’t stopped our club’s esteemed decision makers from extending his stay until at least the end of next season. 


I get that fans moan whether there is something to moan about or not but you have to question what the people in charge have been watching. Paasi is currently averaging around 65 metres a game with ball in hand, a stat padded like Joan Collins’ shoulders by the 93 he made against a woeful Castleford side this week. And most of that was on one run which set up a try for Tristan Sailor. Sad to say that Paasi - who let’s remember will be 34 before the start of next season - has been largely ineffective this year. Even in defence he’s only offering around 14 tackles per game. 


Paasi has been a decent acquisition since be arrived from New Zealand Warriors in December 2020. And it may be true that his dip in productivity owes something to the disgraceful assault on his knee carried out by John Asiata in the 2023 Challenge Cup semi-final. But even if you accept that the decline is not his fault or even due to his ageing that sort of sentiment doesn’t tend to help build title winning teams. 


We should have thanked him for five years good service and let him go. That we didn’t is a decision which - other than naive sentiment - can only have been judged on finance. He’s going to be a lot cheaper than Josh Papali’i. When you tie that in with the club’s decision to vote for 14 teams in the division - which seems purely driven by a desire to have more home games without the unpopular loophole fixtures - shouldn’t be massively surprising. 


Nor was Saints’ latest win, really. Having had a week off from the split round Paul Wellens’ side welcomed a Castleford Tigers side in a fair amount of disarray. There were signs of life when they were mugged by a monumentally bad video referee call in their defeat by Wigan. To which they responded by sacking Head Coach Danny McGuire. Chris Chester absolutely doesn’t want to be a coach again but is doing all the things that you see coaches do during live games. But he has given Brett Delaney a headset to make it look better. Optics. 


Meanwhile Wellens has developed an aversion to picking George Whitby at halfback. He prefers Moses Mbye. It seemed reasonable not to change a winning combination after an unexpected success at Leeds but the attacking performance in the 16-4 home defeat by Leigh which followed surely justified a rethink. 


Wellens did restore both Mark Percival and Daryl Clark to the lineup after they had missed the Leopards game through assorted health issues. Whitby’s bench spot went to the returning Jake Burns. Matt Whitley moved back to his favoured second row slot while Jake Wingfield dropped to the bench. 


A 40-0 win sounds like something to celebrate and there were some genuinely impressive and thrilling moments. It only took Percival five minutes to get back among the try scorers even if it did look like Harry Robertson had knocked on in the buildup. Robertson himself provided the moment of the match when - close to half-time - he plucked a crossfield kick out of the air and went 90 metres to score. You had to pinch yourself a bit to make sure Saints really had scored from that sort of distance but when it sunk in it was glorious. 


Meanwhile Owen Dagnall - in the side largely due to Lewis Murphy’s inability to avoid injury - bagged the seventh try of his nine-game Saints career with a mesmeric individual effort. Having found himself in space thanks to good ball movement from Morgan Knowles, Mbye, Sailor and Percival the young winger had support. But he chose the difficult - some might say wrong route - in kicking ahead to the left hand corner. Astonishingly, he won the race to touch down according to the video referee. It looked like simultaneous contact between him and a Castleford defender so that seemed fair enough. 


It would be easy to get carried away by Dagnall. I remember writing some very positive things about Jon Bennison when he emerged into the first team and he’s currently on loan at Widnes. But the signs around Dagnall are awfully promising. Which could be bad news for Murphy. Or would be if we didn’t have a Head Coach who is wedded to safe options. He has largely only managed to blood youngsters because of a lengthy injury list. 


The other captivating feature of this performance was Saints’ defence. We’ve established that Cas were about as threatening as half the league will be if the club owners get their way, but to record another clean sheet even in this league is something to shout about. In fact, Saints have conceded only 16 points in total over the last three league games. And they managed to lose one of those. Which shows you exactly where the real issue lies with this side. 


This is the second best defence in Super League but we sit only fourth in the table. We somehow have the third best attack in terms of points scored but they can be tortuous to watch. It’s a state of affairs which probably says something horrifying about the standard of the league. But yeah, let’s bring in two more teams and get rid of anyone foreign. 


Next week’s visit to the Giants looks another foregone conclusion. Good news for Saints in the pursuit of a top four place but possibly more bad optics for the league. Salford will be playing somewhere, so that’s two of next week’s six fixtures which are a write-off for neutrals. 


Before that there’s the thrilling prospect of a trip to Wakefield this Friday night. The pair have already met twice but you know…loop fixtures. Saints did win the other two so that might inspire some confidence. At the risk of hubris on a Washington Sundar scale Saints can win they’ll go six points clear of Trinity who currently sit in the sixth and final playoff place. Defeat would bring Daryl Powell’s side to within one win of Saints which really doesn’t bear thinking about.


There has been the slight suggestion that Jack Welsby might be included in the squad having trained this week. He was touted to be absent for the rest of the regular season with a more modest target of returning for the playoffs. So if he can return early that would be a welcome boost. Even if it would make us look like one of those arsehole clubs from Ray French’s broadcasting pomp who pretend that their star players are out injured before conducting performative pre-match fitness tests ahead of the game. I’m looking at you, Wigan. 


The Giants follow on August 17 but there are still scary fixtures ahead. Hull KR, Wigan and Leigh are all on the schedule - none of which I expect us to win - but there is another home game with Castleford for those of you looking for a safety net. 


And if we miss the playoffs this year they’ll probably let 12 teams in next year.


A Short Pause For Thought

With the current Super League round spread over two weeks Saints have no game until they host Castleford Tigers on August 1. That gives us a chance to pause, take a much needed deep breath and delve into not only what’s transpired so far in 2025 but also what lies ahead for the rest of the season and beyond. 


Despite a bumpy ride Saints are still in a position which makes qualifying for the playoffs likely. Paul Wellens’ side sit fifth in the table with eight matches remaining. They are three points clear of Hull FC in sixth and four better off than Wakefield Trinity in seventh. 


All of which is no disgrace, but it isn’t quite what I had hoped for or even what I expected before the season started. I had Saints pegged for a top four spot. That’s still possible but seems unlikely given the side’s inconsistency. But you only need to be inside that six to give yourself a chance.


A couple of pleasantly surprising victories over Leeds Rhinos and one ugly but massive win at Hull FC have eased fears about missing out on the playoffs for what would be the first time in the Super League era. That was a genuine concern just a few months ago. 


When Saints lost to the Rhinos at the Magic Weekend at the start of May there was a significant possibility of missing out on the knockout games. It was a third defeat on the spin after going down to Warrington and Wigan in April. Challenging the top sides - and Warrington - was becoming a task out of reach. You looked at the schedule at that point and couldn’t see where the wins were coming from.


The reasons for our struggles are something which - unusually - most Saints fans would agree with me on. The attack is horrific. Only Alex Walmsley gets us down the field. When he does the players charged with providing creativity look frazzled. Lacking ideas, travelling down blind alleys and some berserk last tackle plays have made us easy to defend against. 


Injuries have played a part. At one point during a game earlier in the season we were running with a three-quarter line of Jon Bennison, Dayon Sambou, Matt Whitley and Curtis Sironen. You wouldn’t overly worry a Championship defence with that combination. 


Kyle Feldt, Mark Percival and Lewis Murphy have all faced spells out while a sensible explanation of the decision to award Konrad Hurrell a one-year deal at the start of 2025 has not been forthcoming. He’s made as many first team appearances this year as I have. 


Jack Welsby is the main creative force in the side and in the league. He’s skilful, strong, surprisingly quick and plays with the kind of swagger normally reserved for stage performers. Yet he’s also out with a long term injury, blunting Saints’ attack even further. 


In the forwards both specialist hookers - Daryl Clark and Jake Burns - missed last week’s 16-4 defeat at home to Leigh Leopards with concussions. Noah Stephens is out long term after having thumb surgery. 


Hull bound pair Joe Batchelor and James Bell have been absent for most of the season through injury also. Bell was named in the initial 21-man squad for Leigh but didn’t feature. Yet he and Batchelor were fit enough to play in the reserve fixture between these two clubs. Either their decision to move east has put Wellens’ nose out of joint or he really does rate Jake Wingfield higher than either. Which baffles me more than a particularly fiendish episode of Only Connect. 


That Saints are still in line for a playoff spot owes much to their defensive solidity. They have Super League’s second best defence having conceded an average of only just over 11 points per game. Only league leaders Hull KR can top that. 


Does it mean that Wellens’ earlier assertion that 18 points should be enough to win any game is right? Maybe, but on the one hand Saints have regularly failed to reach 18 points and on the other it’s not an attitude I want verbalised by the Head Coach of a team which I was drawn to by flair and excitement as much as local pride.


So where does that team go from here? The home defeat by Leigh was a painful reminder of the limitations of the red vee. They’re just not managing to compete with the other top 6 sides. Bar Leeds whom they seem to have some kind of weird spell on. Thankfully there are enough of the league’s dead wood on the schedule to offer Saints a route to the post season.


After this week’s break Castleford Tigers will paying the first of two visits. They have improved recently despite the bonkers dismissal of Danny McGuire. They should have beaten Wigan - though everyone is beating Wigan with Bevvy out injured - and they did beat Warrington. Yet despite these signs of life you would still back Saints against the Tigers at home. 


After that there’s a trip to a Wakefield side which Saints have beaten twice already this year, before struggling Huddersfield come to St Helens on August 17. This run of games has the potential to get Saints to 30 points. By happy coincidence that figure was enough to get Wellens’ men into the six last year. 


Which is good news because it gets a little trickier after that. Schizophrenic Hull FC arrive on August 22 while Saints go to Rovers a week later. September brings a visit from Wigan and a journey to Leigh before the regular season wraps up with another home game against the Tigers. 


It may be a tad too early to speculate but if results go as I envisage Saints could face an away date at Leeds or Leigh in the first playoff round. Saints’ recent record at Headingley could make them a slight favourite but I would be less optimistic about marching into the LSV and emerging unscathed. 


But the beauty of it all, and why you can never write off the season, is that the playoff system will reward the teams with form and fitness at the right time. This will always give Saints a punchers’ chance regardless of whether performances in 2025 merit it. But yeah, to tweak the famous Mike Tyson quote just a little, everyone thinks they have a chance until they get punched in the mouth.


Whatever happens for the remainder of this year there is plenty to mull over for 2026. The club often trots out the mantra that they don’t like to comment on comings and goings until deals are done. That’s fair enough but it leaves us all wondering about a number of key issues which have to be addressed.


Perhaps most important is the question of whether Wellens will be in charge beyond the end of this season. It’s fair to say his tenure hasn’t been spectacular. Some of the performances - like the most recent one against Leigh - have been apologetic. The team selection was barmy, muddled thinking which led to having to juggle an inadequate 15-man rotation. 


And it isn’t the first time. If Wellens does go he might reflect that naming Jonny Lomax on the bench and hauling Bennison off half an hour into that Magic defeat against Leeds was a key moment where he started to show his limitations as a coach. 


He hasn’t been helped by recruitment and retention. At the time of writing the likes of Sironen, Whitley, Bennison, Hurrell and Moses Mbye are all off contract while it has been confirmed that along with Bell and Batchelor Morgan Knowles will leave the club at the end of the season. 


There are more players off contract and Lomax and Walmsley will be 35 and 36 respectively when next season comes around. And how long can injury prone Percival go on as he also enters his 30s? Deon Cross provides more than decent cover but he has also picked up an injury barely half a dozen outings with his hometown team.


On the face of it major surgery is required. Home grown youngsters like Owen Dagnall, George Whitby, Stephens, George Delaney and Harry Robertson offer hope that they will be able to step up regularly and limit the amount of tinkering required. Dagnall’s match winning moment at Leeds showed that he is comfortable at the level required. 


But can we rely on these inexperienced guys consistently? If not there is a very real danger that too many new faces will be required and the side will need time to gel. It would be reassuring for fans to get some idea of what the plan is in terms of the coaching position and the makeup of next year’s squad sooner rather than later.


At certain points this season we have been mercilessly reminded that the famed four in a row hasn’t made Saints eternally bulletproof. Other sides - in particular Leeds and Warrington - have gone through periods of mediocrity after enjoying spells of relative success. We are not immune. 


I think we’ll be fine this year but the future is somewhat cloudier. 


Crippling Vaccilation And Anaemia On A Troubling Night...

It has been a strange but significant week in rugby league.  On Tuesday (July 15) Nigel Wood’s return as interim RFL chairman was given a more permanent footing, much to the chagrin of pretty much everybody who isn’t a self-serving Super League club chairman who positively honks of cash.  Sport England were not happy bunnies either, muttering darkly that if Wood’s return to power had not been done properly and above board then funding could and would be withdrawn. 

Properly installed or not, Wood has failed before.  His return to prominence is the rugby league equivalent of electing Liz Truss back into power at Number 10.  The net result of a semi-coup from a cartel of the moneyed, who bizarrely can do no wrong in the eyes of an indecent number of the not so moneyed.  Your average person seems perfectly willing to take a bullet for a billionaire. 

t was against this backdrop that Saints hosted Leigh Leopards on Thursday night (July 17).  Perhaps thinking that if Wood is back in charge of our destiny as a sport then nothing matters any more, Saints Head Coach Paul Wellens had some fun with his team selection.  Perceived wisdom is that you fill your interchange bench with forwards so that you can rotate them sufficiently to save their energy.  But to Hell with perceived wisdom.  We’re playing Welloball so why not have two backs on the bench just for shits and giggles? 

Jon Bennison, a man for whom the wilderness has become home, was one while teenage halfback George Whitby was the other.  Saints had only one fit number 9 with recent Super League experience in Moses Mbye, so of course he was named at halfback.  It looked like more of the muddled thinking which characterised the Magic Weekend defeat to Leeds in early May, a day when Bennison became an outcast and Saints limped to a 17-4 defeat. 

Mark Percival must have picked up some sort of injury in his comeback game against the Rhinos last week as he was absent along with foot injury victim Deon Cross.  That led Matt Whitley back to the centres.  Despite being named in the 21-man squad 48 hours before kick-off James Bell did not feature which meant that Matty Lees moved from prop to cover Whitley’s second row spot and George Delaney stepped up from the bench to start. 

With Mybe initially named at halfback Jake Wingfield was the unfortunate soul asked to impersonate a hooker.  That misguided decision was seemingly remedied when Mbye went off for an HIA midway through the first half.  He returned but did so at hooker as Whitby – who had replaced him – remained at halfback.  Not that it changed much on one of those nights when Whitby reminded us all that he still has some distance to travel before his is the second coming of Alex Murphy.  B

Back rower Leon Cowen made the bench for a potential debut which left that beacon of the underwhelming Agnatius Paasi as Saints’ only experienced forward on the interchange bench.  It doesn’t feel too harsh to point out that this was a shit show of a team selection for which injuries are no sensible excuse.  To add to the madness Cowen was used for only the last two minutes, time enough for one carry.  Bennison saw no action at all and will presumably return to his natural habitat in the wilderness as soon as any of Percival, Cross, Daryl Clark, Jake Burns etc.. return. 

I had of course read the team news on Twitter, reposting it from That Saints Blog as I did.  Yet as it was read out in the stadium before kick-off I swear I could hear the low hum of an alleged 11.800 people expressing something between discontent, outrage and perplexity.  As the announcer got through introducing the players and their sponsors and arrived at Wellens I half expected the boss to be sponsored by Crippling Vaccilation. 

This has become something of a grudge match in recent years.  Saints fans don’t seem to like Leigh very much these days.  Perhaps this stems from the infamous 2023 Challenge Cup semi-final when the Leopards beat Saints on the way to winning the trophy for the first time in 52 years and in which John Asiata – now sitting in the Hull FC stands with his various injuries – ended the seasons of both Paasi and Alex Walmsley with a couple of criminal tackles which barely met the definition of that word.

But also, Leigh are good now.  And anybody who becomes good becomes unpopular.  Leigh embody this, as do Hull KR who have suddenly thrilled every rugby league fan of a different persuasion by losing a couple of games recently.  Remember when they ran last in the Covid season after the withdrawal of Toronto and everyone commented on what great rugby they played?  Those days are gone now.  It is easy to pat someone on the head if they are 11th and last and no threat.  Not so much if they are top of the league and have  won the Challenge Cup more recently than you have. As Leigh’s threat has grown and Saints’ dominance has withered away, relations have soured.

In this latest meeting things started out ok.  It wasn’t particularly exciting.  One of those games the modern fan enjoys which are physical and include endless completed sets without the threat of anything as vulgar as scoring.  But at that point Saints were well in it.  I was hoping for a bit more.  After all I was missing the Lionesses for this.  But in the context of our pursuit of a place in the race for third place we were sailing along quite nicely.  Only a couple of minor disciplinary indiscretions  brought any points to proceedings in the first half. 

Former Saints loanee Gareth O’Brien slotted over two penalty goals to give the Leopards a 4-0 halftime lead.  One came via a Kyle Feldt dropout which went out on the full.  It was not to be one of the former North Queenland Cowboy’s better nights in the red vee.  But he wasn’t alone in that. Jonny Lomax also skewed an attempted touch finder into the third row as Saints – a team not blessed with accurate territorial kickers – saw even their own modest radar malfunction.   Still it remained tight.  As much as the Saints attack looked again like 13 blokes who had never met, Adrian Lam’s side were not exactly brimming with threat either.  Euphemistically you could describe it as attritional. A first half during which the try scoring music of the last home game – Rhinestone Cowboy anyone? – never realistically looked like being dusted off and taken for a spin.

Saints’ best chance of the first half fell to Owen Dagnall who continues to deputise for Lewis Murphy on the left wing.  He raced on to a kick towards the in-goal and desperately tried to ground the ball.  He didn’t really get close, which didn’t stop him from celebrating it in the most Ryan Atkins way imaginable.  Atkins sits eighth on the all-time Super League scoring charts with 186.  If he had been awarded every try he celebrated with genuine enthusiasm he would be well ahead of the 260 bagged by the current record holder Ryan Hall.  To read Dagnall’s body language in the aftermath you would have been convinced that he had scored.  Alas he did not, and it was a while before Saints got close again.

Isaac Liu was also denied a score after he burrowed his way over following Josh Charnley’s bat back of a Lachlan Lam bomb.  Inside the ground we never got a look at Liu’s grounding so something was clearly amiss before that.  Perhaps Charnley – who openly admitted in a roundabout way this week that he would rather be in Wigan – was offside from the kick.  Or maybe his bat back was a bat forward.  Either way the try did not stand and nobody seemed too perturbed about it. Although Derek was unavailable comment.

It is amusing to listen to the Leigh fans chant ‘Leopards Till I Die’ when what they mean is ‘Leopards Until Derek Changes The Branding Again’.  Unfortunately, by the time we heard this chant go up any amusement at their cringeworthy Bet Lynch rebrand was somewhat tempered by the inevitability of a home defeat to a side we would have expected to put 40 points on not that long ago.  It was Leigh’s first win against Saints in the town of St Helens since 1982.  Some 43 years ago.  But it likely means that third place and a home playoff are a distant dream when they were within very realistic reach before kick-off. 

In the end it was a lapse of discipline which helped end the try drought.  Saints conceded a penalty inside their own half and from the ensuing set former Brisbane Broncos, Wests Tigers and Parramatta Eels man Joe Ofahengaue crashed over.  About 20 minutes remained, which was about a minute less than should have been left on the clock after time was ludicrously allowed to run on during a captain’s challenge a few minutes earlier.  Bloody Chris Kendall.  O’Brien’s first conversion was straightforward.  Even a 10-0 deficit with a quarter of the game remaining looked a big mountain to climb for a ragged Saints outfit trying to employ a 15-man rotation against a top three side. 

Edwin Ipape should have made a decisive contribution seven minutes from the end.  He sliced through the middle of a tiring defence but chose the wrong option to his left when he had men in support on both sides.  The final Leigh try – I would say it was the killer blow if I believed that Saints would otherwise have come out of a 10-point hole – arrived when Feldt endured another catastrophe.  He has been one of the best diffusers of the aerial ball in Super League in 2025.  A one-man bomb disposal unit.  But he was bound to fluff one sooner or later.  When he did it was Ofahengaue who was on hand to profit. O’Brien’s second conversion pushed Lam’s men out to an unassailable 16-0 lead. 

Saints had not been nilled on their own patch in over 10 years.  That was in the World Club Challenge in 2015 when South Sydney Rabbitohs arrived with Russel Crowe and Djimon Honsou and left with the World Club Challenge Trophy after putting on a 38-0 clinic.  As much as they have improved and deserve their place among the genuine elite of Super League in 2025 this Leigh side do not deserve to be in that company.  So it was with some relief that Harry Robertson managed to cross for a consolation in the final minute.  It was Robertson’s ninth try of an injury-interrupted season and also provided us with Tristan Sailor’s 20th assist of the season.                                                                                       

It was little consolation on what was a troubling night.  But perhaps we shouldn’t be too downhearted.  A couple of wins against Castleford at home and one against Huddersfield should see us collect enough points to at least reach the playoffs.  And we still have a return match with Leigh and a visit from Hull FC on the schedule – games in which more points are a realistic prospect. 

Yet there is no getting away from the fact that massive improvements on this showing will be required if we are to challenge the Leopards next time.  Saints have now scored 10 points in their last two Super League fixtures and only 23 in the last three.  The attack is positively anaemic.  An early playoff exit is on the cards unless Wellens – helped by Lee Briers – can instil a bit of joie de vivre into stulted, safety first attacking displays.  The problem is that he has not shown us at any point that he has either the appetite or the capability to do that.  He thinks we are crap because we are inpatient.  We’re crap because we’re crap.

It's a week off next week as Round 20 is split into two halves, with the remaining fixtures played on the following weekend.  What looks a distinctly Australian Origin-esque plan is actually there to make up for the lack of a mid-season international fixture.  Apparently there isn’t much call for another 50-point stroll over a French side which refuses to improve despite 19 years of exposure to the Super League standard.  It does at least mean that Saints won’t lose for a fortnight.  But they won’t score any points either. 

If the picture seems bleak console yourself with this.  Nigel is back.  Oh…

Steele Retchless, 18+ And A Lack Of Hookers…

I’m paraphrasing, but earlier this season Paul Wellens said something along the lines of ‘18 points should be enough to win any game of rugby league’. 

The purists among us balked at this proclamation.  It was anti-rugby.  It wasn’t even true, or so we thought.  Before Friday night’s attritional 6-0 win over Leeds Rhinos at Headingley Saints had won only three times this season when scoring 18 points or fewer.  They have lost on all six of the other occasions that they failed to better that tally. 

Though still the second best defence in Super League in terms of points conceded this is not the rock solid and resilient team of the Kristian Woolf era.  It cannot always be relied on. More often than not Saints will need to surpass Wellens’ magic number to secure the win. And if they want to keep me awake.

But that second best defence turned up on this occasion.  Between them Matty Lees and Morgan Knowles put in Steele Retchless-esque performances, tackling anything that moved - and a few Leeds forwards who seemed not to - as Saints stifled Brad Arthur’s recently improved side. The Saints pair made a preposterous 109 tackles between them with Lees coming up with 58 in an 80-minute stint of indefatigable industry. 

The duck egg next to the Rhinos is no mean feat. The only other side to have nilled them in Super League this year is Catalans Dragons in a truly dreadful 11-0 success in early March.  And that was a vastly different Leeds from the one which has been busy toppling Hull KR, Leigh and Warrington in recent weeks.

Aside from the Dragons the team which came closest to shutting the Rhinos out before this game was…er…Saints.  Wellens’ side triumphed 18-4 at home against the blue and amber a month ago.  In four meetings with the Rhinos in league and cup in 2025 Saints have conceded only 35 points at an average of less than nine points per game.  

One dreadful performance at Newcastle aside Saints seem to have what NRL types might call the wood over the West Yorkshire outfit in 2025. Even the sin-binning of Agnatius Paasi with 15 minutes to go for a euphemistically careless forearm to the head of Alfie Edgell was not enough to see them yield and relinquish their spankingly clean sheet. Though it does help when legend in his own back yard Jake Connor is throwing cut out balls to punters in the third row. 

Paasi was issued with three penalty points by the disciplinary committee for his indiscretion as was Jonny Lomax for a dangerous tackle early in the game. If you understand the new disciplinary system you are one up on me but the bottom line is that both have avoided suspension and are available this week. Which would have been unimaginable this time last season when suspensions were very much in vogue. Yet so would the prospect of Nigel Wood making decisions on the game’s future once more but here we are.

As impressive as this Saints performance was I also found it excruciating.  I hate these sorts of games.  I want to see mistakes, missed tackles, breaks, scoring opportunities.  I want to see Lees - an England squad member considered among the best front rowers in Super League - average more than 82 metres per game with ball in hand. And let me add that he fell some way short of that modest median in this one. Too busy tackling. Completed set after completed set leaves me cold irrespective of how difficult it is to play 80 minutes at prop and continuously tackle Mikolaj Oledzki.  

I do have to doff my metaphorical cap to Owen Dagnall both for his overall performance and in particular for providing the decisive moment in the contest. Fed by Tristan Sailor close to the left touchline the youngster got rid of Harry Newman and stepped inside Lachie Miller to score the game’s only try. It was a classy moment from Dagnall who is beginning to make a case for his inclusion even when Jack Welsby, Lewis Murphy and Deon Cross are all fit again.

Dagnall was superb but he wasn’t infallible by any means. Later, his inability to diffuse a Leeds bomb led to the Rhinos’ best opportunity to bother the scoreboard operator but Miller was rightly adjudged to have nudged Mark Percival in the back in the build up to Edgell’s effort. He may not have grounded it anyway as the Saints defence scrambled to push him towards touch.

Grumbles notwithstanding I commend the red vee boys for the achievement of the clean sheet and for securing another unlikely win which makes them all but a certainty for the playoffs. They were briefly a vertigo inducing third in the table before the Leopards surprised Rovers on Saturday (July 12). 

Currently fourth, Saints have 24 points. A couple of wins over Castleford and one over Huddersfield will get them to the 30-point mark which came with a top six spot last year and almost certainly will again. Wins against the better sides still on the schedule are almost a bonus now. So with a modicum of pressure off will the Saints attack liven things up a bit when Leigh come to town on Thursday? 

They’ll be handicapped by the lack of a natural number nine. Both Daryl Clark and Jake Burns left the Headingley scene with head injuries and are ruled out of the visit of Adrian Lam’s side due to concussion protocols. As it stands the only man likely to be in the squad with any regular Super League experience at hooker is Moses Mbye and he has been playing halfback for the last few weeks. 

It would seem a good time then to recall George Whitby to the side. He has missed the last two after sustaining a concussion but was fit enough to turn out for the reserves on the eve of this win. Unfortunately Noah Stephens will not feature after he had surgery for a thumb injury which is likely to keep him out for a couple of months. Not that he was used much anyway. Jake Wingfield has been mystifyingly preferred and his occasional stints at dummy half would seem to hint towards a more justifiable inclusion for this one.

Somehow this will be Saints’ first meeting with Leigh in 2025 despite having met both Leeds and Salford three times each in the madcap world of loop fixtures. It’s a tricky assignment but it’s an opportunity. As unlikely as it seemed after Magic or chastening defeats by Hull KR and Wigan earlier in the year Saints could still finish in the top three. Higher if you believe the Twitter theories about a Hull KR collapse. Which I don’t. But now that Saints are starting to beat other playoff contenders instead of merely punching down on bottom feeders a top three finish doesn’t seem that fanciful. 

But it will probably take more than 18 points to get the run for home started with a win against the Leopards.


England And The Idea Of Jake Connor

Sorry Wakefield fans but the news cycle stops for nobody. There's a World Cup to be won.  Former military man Brian McDermott is the man...